# Solution Draft (Rev 02) ## Revised Constraints (vs Draft 01) | Constraint | Draft 01 | Draft 02 | |-----------|----------|----------| | Cost per unit | $100k prototype | < $7k, target < $5k | | Material | CFRP (T700) | S2 fiberglass (radio transparent) | | Radio transparency | Not considered | Required — full RF transparency for GPS, telemetry, data links | | Flight time | 5-6 hours target | Same if possible, can be less | | Transport | Not specified | Disassembled fits in car trunk; 2 planes per pickup truck | ## Product Solution Description A modular, radio-transparent electric fixed-wing reconnaissance UAV built with **S2 fiberglass/foam-core sandwich construction** with internal **carbon fiber spar reinforcement**. Designed for field deployment — disassembles into 3 sections (2 wing panels + fuselage) that fit in a car trunk, with 2 complete aircraft fitting in a standard pickup truck bed. Powered by semi-solid state batteries for maximum endurance. **Target performance**: 3.5-5 hours practical flight endurance, 9-10 kg MTOW, ~3m wingspan, < $5k BOM per unit. ``` ┌──────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐ │ MODULAR AIRFRAME LAYOUT │ │ │ │ LEFT WING PANEL FUSELAGE RIGHT WING PANEL │ │ (~1.5m span) (~1.0-1.1m) (~1.5m span) │ │ ┌──────────────┐ ┌──────────────┐ ┌──────────────┐ │ │ │ S2 FG skin │ │ S2 FG skin │ │ S2 FG skin │ │ │ │ PVC foam core│◄─►│ Battery bay │◄─►│ PVC foam core│ │ │ │ CF spar cap │ │ Payload bay │ │ CF spar cap │ │ │ │ (internal) │ │ Motor+ESC │ │ (internal) │ │ │ └──────────────┘ └──────────────┘ └──────────────┘ │ │ │ │ Wing-fuselage joint: aluminum spar joiner + 2 pin locks │ │ Assembly time target: < 10 minutes │ │ Material: S2 fiberglass = RF transparent (GPS/telemetry OK) │ │ Internal CF spar: minimal RF impact (narrow linear element) │ └──────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┘ TRANSPORT CONFIGURATION (standard pickup truck, 6.5ft bed): ┌───────────────────────────────────────────┐ │ Truck bed: 198cm × 130cm (wheel wells) │ │ ┌──────────────────┐ ┌────────────────┐ │ │ │ Plane 1 wings │ │ Plane 2 wings │ │ │ │ (2 × 150cm long) │ │ (2 × 150cm) │ │ │ │ stacked ~20cm │ │ stacked ~20cm │ │ │ ├──────────────────┤ ├────────────────┤ │ │ │ Plane 1 fuselage │ │ Plane 2 fuse. │ │ │ │ (~110cm) │ │ (~110cm) │ │ │ └──────────────────┘ └────────────────┘ │ │ Total width: ~60cm × 2 = 120cm < 130cm ✓│ │ Total length: 150cm < 198cm ✓ │ └───────────────────────────────────────────┘ ``` ## Existing/Competitor Solutions Analysis | Platform | MTOW | Endurance | Payload | Material | RF Transparent | Modular | Price | |----------|------|-----------|---------|----------|---------------|---------|-------| | Albatross (kit) | 10 kg | 4 hours | 4.5 kg | Fiberglass + CF | Partial | No (removable wings) | $1,500 kit | | Albatross (RTF) | 10 kg | 4 hours | 4.5 kg | Fiberglass + CF | Partial | No | $4,800 | | DeltaQuad Evo | 10 kg | 4.5h / 8.9h record | 1-3 kg | FG + CF + Kevlar | Partial | Wing removable | $25,000+ | | Skywalker X8 | ~4 kg | 45-60 min | 1-2 kg | EPO foam | Yes | No | $489-598 | | Mugin 2600 | 15 kg | 1.5-5h | 4 kg | Carbon fiber | No | Wing sections | $2,299+ | **Key insight**: The Albatross kit at $1,500 proves that a 3m wingspan composite airframe is achievable at very low cost. Our target of < $5k per complete unit (with batteries) is realistic. No competitor offers the combination of radio transparency + modular transport + semi-solid batteries. ## Architecture ### Component: Frame Material | Solution | Advantages | Limitations | Cost (per unit) | Fit | |----------|-----------|-------------|----------------|-----| | **S2 fiberglass skin + PVC foam core + internal CF spar (recommended)** | RF transparent skin, strong internal structure, good impact tolerance, easy to repair, $8-19/m² fabric | ~30-40% heavier than pure CFRP for equivalent stiffness | Fabric: $200-400; foam: $100-200; CF spar material: $50-100; resin: $80-150; total materials: $430-850 | ✅ Best balance of RF transparency, cost, repairability | | E-glass fiberglass (instead of S2) | Cheapest glass option (~$3-5/m²), RF transparent, easy to work | 40% weaker than S2, requires thicker layup → heavier | Materials: $200-500 | ⚠️ Acceptable budget option, slightly heavier | | Pure S2 fiberglass (no CF spar) | Maximum RF transparency, simplest construction | Insufficient wing stiffness at low weight, flutter risk | Materials: $300-600 | ❌ Stiffness deficit at acceptable weight | | Pure CFRP (draft 01 approach) | Lightest, stiffest | Blocks RF — GPS/telemetry degraded, expensive | Materials: $800-1500 | ❌ Fails radio transparency requirement | **Recommendation**: S2 fiberglass skin over PVC foam core with unidirectional carbon fiber spar caps (top and bottom of main spar, internal). The CF spar is a narrow linear element (~20-30mm wide per cap) inside the wing — negligible RF blockage. All external surfaces are S2 FG = fully radio transparent. ### Component: Construction Method | Solution | Advantages | Limitations | Cost | Fit | |----------|-----------|-------------|------|-----| | **Vacuum-bagged foam sandwich (recommended)** | Good quality (53% stronger than hand layup), low tooling cost, reproducible | Requires vacuum pump + consumables | Equipment: $500 one-time; consumables: $50-100/unit | ✅ Best for low-cost production | | Hand layup over foam core | Cheapest, simplest, no equipment needed | Lower quality (more voids), less consistent | Minimal equipment | ⚠️ Acceptable for prototypes only | | Vacuum infusion | Best quality (71% stronger than hand layup) | More complex setup, higher consumable cost | Equipment: $1000+; consumables: $100-200/unit | ⚠️ Worth it at higher volume (>20 units) | | Outsourced prepreg manufacturing | Highest quality | Expensive per unit at low volume | $2000-5000/airframe | ❌ Exceeds per-unit budget | ### Component: Foam Core | Solution | Advantages | Limitations | Cost/m² | Fit | |----------|-----------|-------------|---------|-----| | **PVC Divinycell H60 (recommended)** | Good stiffness/weight, closed-cell, 80°C tolerant, industry standard | More expensive than XPS | $50-80/m² | ✅ Best value for production | | XPS (extruded polystyrene) | Cheapest closed-cell, easy to shape with hot wire | Lower compressive strength, 75°C limit | $10-20/m² | ✅ Good budget alternative | | EPS (expanded polystyrene) | Very cheap | Absorbs moisture, lowest strength | $5-10/m² | ⚠️ Only for non-critical areas | ### Component: Wing-Fuselage Joint (Modular Assembly) | Solution | Advantages | Limitations | Cost | Fit | |----------|-----------|-------------|------|-----| | **Aluminum spar joiner + pin locks (recommended)** | Quick assembly (<5 min), proven in RC/UAV, high strength, replaceable | Adds ~100-150g per joint (200-300g total) | $30-60 machined aluminum parts | ✅ Simple, reliable, fast | | 3D-printed spar connector with hinge | Very fast assembly (<2 min), lightweight | Lower strength, fatigue concerns, requires testing | $10-20 per set | ⚠️ Good for prototype, risky for production | | Bolted flange joint | Very strong, proven in full-scale aviation | Heavier (~200g per joint), slower assembly (10+ min) | $20-40 | ⚠️ Over-engineered for this scale | **Design**: Wing spar is a carbon fiber tube or C-channel running the full wing half-span. At the root, it slides into an aluminum joiner tube embedded in the fuselage. Secured with 2 quick-release pins (top and bottom). Electrical connections (servo leads) via a quick-disconnect plug at each wing root. ### Component: Battery Technology | Solution | Energy density | Endurance impact | Cycle life | Cost/pack | Fit | |----------|---------------|-----------------|------------|-----------|-----| | **Semi-solid Tattu 330Wh/kg 6S (recommended)** | 315 Wh/kg pack | Baseline (best) | 800-1200 | ~$800-1200 est. | ✅ Best endurance per $ | | Semi-solid Grepow 300Wh/kg 6S | 280-300 Wh/kg pack | -5 to -10% | 1200+ | ~$700-1000 est. | ✅ Good alternative | | Li-Ion 21700 custom pack (6S) | 200-220 Wh/kg pack | -25 to -35% | 500-800 | ~$200-400 | ⚠️ Budget option, significant endurance loss | | LiPo 6S (standard RC) | 150-180 Wh/kg pack | -40 to -50% | 200-500 | ~$100-200 | ❌ Too much endurance loss | ## Weight Budget (S2 Fiberglass Build) | Component | Weight (kg) | Notes | |-----------|-------------|-------| | Bare airframe (S2 FG sandwich + CF spar) | 3.8-4.5 | ~30% heavier than pure CFRP; Albatross FG+CF is 3.35 kg | | Wing joints (aluminum) | 0.2-0.3 | Spar joiners + pins + quick-disconnect plugs | | Motor + ESC + propeller | 0.4-0.6 | | | Wiring, connectors, misc | 0.3-0.4 | | | **Platform subtotal** | **4.7-5.8** | | | Payload (camera + gimbal + Jetson + Pixhawk + GPS) | 1.47 | Fixed | | Battery (semi-solid) | 2.7-3.8 | Remainder to MTOW | | **Total (target MTOW 10 kg)** | **~10.0** | | Conservative estimate: platform 5.3 kg + payload 1.47 kg + battery 3.2 kg = 9.97 kg. ## Endurance Estimate (S2 Fiberglass) **Assumptions**: - MTOW: 10 kg - Platform weight: 5.3 kg (S2 FG airframe + motor + wiring + joints) - Payload: 1.47 kg - Battery: 3.23 kg semi-solid at 310 Wh/kg = 1001 Wh - Cruise power: ~140W (slightly higher than CFRP due to heavier aircraft → higher induced drag) - Payload power: ~30W (Jetson + camera + gimbal) - Total system power: ~170W - Battery reserve: 20% - Usable energy: 1001 × 0.80 = 801 Wh - Real-world efficiency factor: 0.75 **Theoretical endurance**: 1001 / 170 = 5.9 hours **Practical endurance (with reserve)**: 801 / 170 ≈ **4.7 hours** **Practical endurance (with reserve + real-world losses)**: 801 × 0.75 / 170 ≈ **3.5 hours** **Comparison to Draft 01 (CFRP)**: - Draft 01: 5.0 hours practical → Draft 02: 3.5-4.7 hours practical - Endurance reduction: ~15-30% depending on conditions - Still competitive with Albatross (4h with LiPo) when using semi-solid batteries **With budget Li-Ion pack instead** (to stay under $5k): - 3.23 kg Li-Ion at 210 Wh/kg = 678 Wh → usable 542 Wh - Practical: 542 / 170 ≈ **3.2 hours** (reserve only) / **2.4 hours** (worst case) ## BOM Cost Estimate (Per Unit) | Component | Low Est. | High Est. | Notes | |-----------|----------|-----------|-------| | S2 fiberglass fabric | $150 | $300 | ~8-10 m² at $15-30/m² | | PVC foam core (Divinycell H60) | $100 | $200 | Wing + fuselage panels | | Epoxy resin + hardener | $80 | $150 | ~2-3 kg resin | | CF spar material (tube + UD tape) | $50 | $100 | Spar caps + tubes | | Aluminum spar joiners (machined) | $30 | $60 | 2 joiner sets, batch machined | | Vacuum bagging consumables | $30 | $60 | Bag, breather, peel ply, tape | | Motor (brushless, ~500W) | $80 | $150 | | | ESC (40-60A) | $40 | $80 | | | Propeller (folding) | $15 | $30 | | | Servos (4× ailerons + elevator + rudder) | $60 | $120 | | | Wiring, connectors, hardware | $50 | $100 | | | Semi-solid battery (Tattu 330Wh/kg 6S 33Ah) | $800 | $1,200 | Single pack | | RC receiver | $30 | $80 | | | Telemetry radio | $100 | $300 | | | Transport case / padded bag | $50 | $150 | | | **Subtotal (airframe + propulsion + battery)** | **$1,665** | **$3,080** | | | Pixhawk 6x + GPS | $300 | $500 | If not already owned | | **Total BOM (without mission payload)** | **$1,965** | **$3,580** | | | **Total BOM (with Pixhawk, without mission payload)** | **$2,265** | **$4,080** | | Manufacturing labor (per unit, assuming in-house build with molds amortized): - First unit (mold making): +$2,000-3,000 tooling - Subsequent units: ~$500-1,000 labor per airframe (8-16 hours assembly) **Per-unit cost at batch of 5+**: **$2,800-4,500** (without mission payload) ✅ Under $5k target **Per-unit cost at batch of 1 (first prototype)**: **$5,000-7,000** (includes tooling) ✅ Under $7k target ## Modular Transport Specifications | Dimension | Value | |-----------|-------| | Wing panel length | ~1.50 m (half-span) | | Wing panel chord | ~0.25-0.30 m | | Wing panel thickness | ~0.04-0.05 m | | Fuselage length | ~1.00-1.10 m | | Fuselage width/height | ~0.15-0.20 m | | Assembly time | < 10 minutes (target) | | Disassembly time | < 5 minutes | **Car trunk fit**: 3 sections (2 wings + fuselage) fit in standard sedan trunk (~120×80×45 cm). Wings stack flat, fuselage alongside. ✅ **Pickup truck (2 planes)**: Standard 6.5ft bed (198×130 cm between wheel wells). Each plane's longest component is 150 cm (< 198 cm bed length). Two planes side by side need ~120 cm width (< 130 cm between wheel wells). ✅ ## Trade-off Summary: S2 Fiberglass vs CFRP | Dimension | S2 Fiberglass (Draft 02) | CFRP (Draft 01) | Winner | |-----------|--------------------------|-----------------|--------| | RF transparency | ✅ Excellent — transparent to GPS, telemetry, data links | ❌ Blocks RF, requires external antennas | S2 FG | | Cost per unit | $2,800-4,500 | $30,000-60,000 (prototype) | S2 FG | | Endurance | 3.5-4.7 hours practical | 5.0 hours practical | CFRP (+15-30%) | | Airframe weight | 3.8-4.5 kg bare | 2.8-3.2 kg bare | CFRP (-25%) | | Impact resistance | Good (fiberglass is tough) | Poor (CFRP is brittle) | S2 FG | | Field repairability | Easy (fiberglass patches, epoxy) | Difficult (specialized repair) | S2 FG | | Manufacturing complexity | Low (basic vacuum bagging) | Medium-High (precise layup) | S2 FG | | Transport / modularity | Same | Same | Tie | **Conclusion**: S2 fiberglass is the clear choice given the revised constraints. The 15-30% endurance reduction vs CFRP is offset by radio transparency (critical for the mission), 10x lower cost, and significantly easier manufacturing and field repair. ## Testing Strategy ### Integration / Functional Tests - Static wing load test: 3× max flight load at spar joiner (verify no failure at 3g) - Wing joint cycling: 100× assembly/disassembly, verify no wear or looseness - RF transparency test: measure GPS signal strength through airframe skin vs free-air (target: < 3 dB attenuation) - Assembly time test: verify < 10 minutes from transport case to flight-ready - Range/endurance test: fly at cruise until 20% reserve, measure actual vs predicted - Payload integration test: all electronics function under vibration ### Non-Functional Tests - Transport test: load 2 planes in pickup truck, drive 100 km on mixed roads, verify no damage - Hard landing test: belly landing at 2 m/s descent, verify structural integrity - Field repair test: simulate wing skin puncture, repair with FG patch + epoxy, verify airworthy in < 30 minutes - Temperature test: battery + avionics function at -10°C and +45°C - Battery cycle test: 50 charge/discharge cycles, verify ≥95% capacity retention ## Production BOM: 5 UAVs From Scratch ### A. One-Time Equipment & Tooling | Item | Qty | Unit Price | Total | Notes | |------|-----|-----------|-------|-------| | **Composite Workshop Equipment** | | | | | | Vacuum pump (6 CFM 2-stage) | 1 | $280 | $280 | VIOT or equivalent | | Vacuum bagging starter kit (gauges, tubing, valves, connectors) | 1 | $150 | $150 | | | Digital scale (0.1g precision, 5 kg capacity) | 1 | $50 | $50 | For resin mixing | | Mixing cups, squeegees, rollers, brushes set | 1 | $80 | $80 | | | Large work table (4×8 ft plywood + sawhorses) | 1 | $150 | $150 | | | Self-healing cutting mat (4×8 ft) | 1 | $80 | $80 | | | **Foam Cutting** | | | | | | CNC hot wire foam cutter (4-axis, DIY kit) | 1 | $350 | $350 | Vortex-RC or similar | | **Mold Making** | | | | | | MDF sheets for plugs (4×8 ft × ¾") | 4 | $45 | $180 | Wing + fuselage plugs | | Tooling epoxy + fiberglass for female molds | 1 | $600 | $600 | 2× wing mold halves + fuselage molds | | Mold release agent (PVA + wax) | 1 | $60 | $60 | | | Filler / fairing compound | 1 | $80 | $80 | For plug finishing | | Sandpaper assortment (80-600 grit) | 1 | $40 | $40 | | | **Metal Work** | | | | | | Aluminum spar joiner machining (batch of 12 sets) | 1 | $400 | $400 | CNC outsourced, 10 sets + 2 spare | | **PPE & Ventilation** | | | | | | Respirator (half-face, organic vapor + P100) | 2 | $40 | $80 | 1 per worker | | Nitrile gloves (box of 200) | 2 | $25 | $50 | | | Safety glasses | 3 | $10 | $30 | | | Portable fume extractor / fan | 1 | $120 | $120 | | | **Hand & Power Tools** | | | | | | Drill + mixing paddle | 1 | $80 | $80 | | | Jigsaw | 1 | $60 | $60 | | | Rotary tool (Dremel) | 1 | $50 | $50 | | | Heat gun | 1 | $35 | $35 | | | Scissors, utility knives, rulers, clamps | 1 | $80 | $80 | Assorted set | | **Charging & Testing** | | | | | | Battery charger (6S/12S balance, 1000W) | 1 | $200 | $200 | | | Multimeter | 1 | $30 | $30 | | | Servo tester | 1 | $15 | $15 | | | **Software & Design** | | | | | | CAD/CAM (FreeCAD / OpenVSP — free) | — | $0 | $0 | Open source | | Hot wire CNC software (included with cutter) | — | $0 | $0 | | | | | | | | | **EQUIPMENT & TOOLING TOTAL** | | | **$3,335** | | ### B. Raw Materials (for 5 UAVs + 20% waste margin) Material quantities per UAV: - Wing skin area: ~1.6 m² planform × 2 (top+bottom) × 2 layers = ~6.4 m² S2 fabric - Fuselage skin: ~0.6 m² × 2 layers = ~1.2 m² - Tail surfaces: ~0.3 m² × 2 layers = ~0.6 m² - Total S2 fabric per UAV: ~8.2 m² → with waste: ~10 m² - Foam core per UAV: ~2.5 m² (wings + tail) - Resin per UAV: ~2.5 kg (fabric weight × 1:1 ratio + extra) | Item | Qty (5 UAVs + margin) | Unit Price | Total | Notes | |------|----------------------|-----------|-------|-------| | **Structural Materials** | | | | | | S2 fiberglass fabric 6oz (30" wide) | 70 yards (~64 m) | $12.50/yard | $875 | ~10 m² per UAV × 5 + waste | | PVC foam Divinycell H60 10mm (1.22×0.81m sheets) | 16 sheets | $40/sheet | $640 | ~2.5 m² per UAV × 5 + waste | | Laminating epoxy resin (West System 105 or equiv) | 4 gallons | $125/gal | $500 | ~2.5 kg resin per UAV | | Epoxy hardener | 2 gallons | $80/gal | $160 | | | Carbon fiber tube (spar, 20mm OD, 1.5m) | 12 | $25 each | $300 | 2 per UAV + spare | | Carbon fiber UD tape (spar caps, 25mm wide) | 30 m | $5/m | $150 | 5m per UAV + spare | | **Vacuum Bagging Consumables** | | | | | | Vacuum bag film (5m × 1.5m rolls) | 6 rolls | $20/roll | $120 | ~1 roll per UAV + spare | | Peel ply fabric | 20 yards | $5/yard | $100 | | | Breather cloth | 20 yards | $4/yard | $80 | | | Sealant tape | 6 rolls | $12/roll | $72 | | | **Hardware (per 5 UAVs)** | | | | | | Aluminum spar joiners | (included in tooling) | — | $0 | Batch machined above | | Quick-release pins (stainless) | 20 | $3 each | $60 | 4 per UAV | | Quick-disconnect electrical plugs | 10 | $8 each | $80 | 2 per UAV (wing roots) | | Misc hardware (bolts, nuts, hinges, control horns) | 5 sets | $30/set | $150 | | | | | | | | | **RAW MATERIALS TOTAL (5 UAVs)** | | | **$3,287** | | | **Per UAV materials** | | | **~$657** | | ### C. Electronics & Propulsion (per UAV × 5) | Item | Qty/UAV | Unit Price | Per UAV | ×5 Total | Notes | |------|---------|-----------|---------|----------|-------| | Motor (brushless ~500W, e.g. Dualsky XM5050EA) | 1 | $90 | $90 | $450 | Fixed-wing optimized | | ESC (40-60A, BLHeli) | 1 | $50 | $50 | $250 | | | Folding propeller (13×8 or similar) | 2 | $15 | $30 | $150 | 1 spare per UAV | | Servos (digital metal gear, 15-20 kg·cm) | 5 | $25 | $125 | $625 | 2× aileron + elevator + rudder + flap/spare | | Pixhawk 6X Mini + GPS | 1 | $380 | $380 | $1,900 | | | RC receiver (long range, e.g. TBS Crossfire) | 1 | $60 | $60 | $300 | | | RFD900x telemetry pair (shared GCS unit) | 1 air + 0.2 GCS | $170 (air) | $170 | $850 + $350 GCS = $1,200 | 1 GCS module shared | | Power distribution board + BEC | 1 | $25 | $25 | $125 | | | Wiring, connectors (XT90, JST, servo ext.) | 1 set | $40 | $40 | $200 | | | Semi-solid battery (Tattu 330Wh/kg 6S 33Ah) | 1 | $732 | $732 | $3,660 | | | | | | | | | | **ELECTRONICS TOTAL (5 UAVs)** | | | | **$8,910** | | | **Per UAV electronics** | | | **~$1,702** | | Excl. shared GCS telemetry | ### D. Consumables & Misc (for 5 UAVs) | Item | Total | Notes | |------|-------|-------| | Transport bags / padded cases (per UAV) | $300 | $60 × 5 (padded wing bags + fuselage bag) | | Battery charger cables + adapters | $50 | | | Field repair kit (S2 FG patches, epoxy sachets, sandpaper) | $150 | $30 × 5 | | Spare hardware kit (pins, bolts, servo horns) | $100 | | | Shipping / freight (materials + components) | $400 | Estimate | | **CONSUMABLES TOTAL** | **$1,000** | | ### E. Labor | Role | People | Duration | Rate | Total | Notes | |------|--------|----------|------|-------|-------| | Mold making + setup (one-time) | 2 | 3 weeks | $30/hr | $7,200 | 2 people × 40h/wk × 3 wk | | Airframe layup + cure (per UAV) | 2 | 3 days | $30/hr | $2,880 | 2 people × 8h × 3 days × 5 UAVs | | Post-cure trim, finish, assembly | 1 | 2 days | $30/hr | $2,400 | 1 person × 8h × 2 days × 5 | | Electronics integration + wiring | 1 | 1.5 days | $35/hr | $2,100 | 1 person × 8h × 1.5 days × 5 | | QA, testing, calibration | 1 | 1 day | $35/hr | $1,400 | 1 person × 8h × 1 day × 5 | | **LABOR TOTAL** | | | | **$15,980** | | | **Per UAV labor** | | | | **~$2,516** | Including amortized mold making | ### F. Production Summary — Total Investment for 5 UAVs | Category | Total | Per UAV | |----------|-------|---------| | A. Equipment & Tooling (one-time) | $3,335 | $667 | | B. Raw Materials | $3,287 | $657 | | C. Electronics & Propulsion | $8,910 | $1,782 | | D. Consumables & Misc | $1,000 | $200 | | E. Labor | $15,980 | $3,196 | | | | | | **GRAND TOTAL (5 UAVs)** | **$32,512** | | | **Per UAV (all-in, including labor)** | | **$6,502** | | **Per UAV (materials + electronics only, no labor)** | | **$3,306** | ### G. Cost Optimization Options | Optimization | Savings/UAV | Impact | |-------------|-------------|--------| | Use XPS foam instead of Divinycell H60 | -$90 | Slightly lower stiffness, acceptable for prototype | | Use E-glass instead of S2 glass | -$100 | ~40% weaker, needs thicker layup → ~200g heavier | | Use Li-Ion 21700 pack instead of Tattu semi-solid | -$400 | Endurance drops from 3.5-4.7h to 2.4-3.2h | | Self-machine spar joiners (manual lathe) | -$50 | Requires metalworking skill | | Use cheaper servos ($15 each) | -$50 | Lower torque, shorter lifespan | | **Aggressive budget build** | **-$690** | **$2,616/UAV materials only** | ### H. Minimum Viable Team | Role | Count | Skills Required | Commitment | |------|-------|----------------|------------| | Composite fabricator | 1-2 | Fiberglass layup, vacuum bagging, mold making | Full-time during build (8 weeks) | | Electronics/avionics tech | 1 | Soldering, Pixhawk configuration, wiring | Part-time (can overlap with fabricator) | | **Minimum: 2 people for 8 weeks** | | | | **Timeline for 5 UAVs**: - Week 1-3: Mold making (CNC foam plugs → fiberglass female molds) - Week 4-5: First 2 airframes layup + cure + trim - Week 5-6: Next 3 airframes layup + cure + trim - Week 6-7: Electronics integration all 5 units - Week 7-8: Testing, calibration, flight testing - **Total: ~8 weeks with 2 people** ### I. Minimal Absolute Cost (No Labor Accounted) If labor is free (owner-operators building their own): | Category | Total | Per UAV | |----------|-------|---------| | Equipment & Tooling | $3,335 | $667 | | Raw Materials | $3,287 | $657 | | Electronics & Propulsion | $8,910 | $1,782 | | Consumables & Misc | $1,000 | $200 | | **TOTAL (5 UAVs, no labor)** | **$16,532** | | | **Per UAV (no labor)** | | **$3,306** | **Absolute minimum per UAV** (with budget optimizations from Section G): **~$2,616** ## References 1-20: See Draft 01 references (all still applicable) Additional sources: 21. S-Glass vs E-Glass comparison: https://wiki-science.blog/s-glass-vs-e-glass-key-differences 22. Reinforcement Fiber Reference: https://explorecomposites.com/materials-library/fiber-ref/ 23. S-Glass vs Carbon Fiber: https://carbonfiberfriend.com/s-glass-vs-carbon-fiber/ 24. RF Attenuation by composite materials: https://www.rocketryforum.com/threads/rf-attenuation-by-body-tube-nosecone.186634/ 25. Russian foamplast UAV (max radio transparency): https://bulgarianmilitary.com/2023/10/15/russia-unveils-foamplast-fpv-uav-with-max-radio-transparency/ 26. Albatross UAV Kit: https://store.appliedaeronautics.com/albatross-uav-kit/ 27. UAV spar connector development: https://www.konelson.net/home/spar-connector-development 28. Scabro Innovations UAV prototyping: https://scabroinnovations.com/diensten/composite-airframe-prototyping/ 29. Tattu 330Wh/kg 6S pricing — GenStattu: https://genstattu.com/tattu-semi-solid-state-330wh-kg-33000mah-10c-22-2v-6s1p-g-tech-lipo-battery-pack-with-xt90-s-plug/ 30. Pixhawk 6X pricing — Holybro: https://holybro.com/products/pixhawk-6x-rev3 31. RFD900x pricing — DrUAV: https://druav.com/products/rfdesign-rfd900x 32. Composite workshop setup — Fibre Glast: https://www.fibreglast.com/blogs/learning-center/setting-up-a-composite-shop 33. CNC hot wire foam cutter — Vortex-RC: https://www.vortex-rc.com/product/4-axis-diy-hot-wire-cnc-for-rc-hobbyists-aeromodellers-and-designers/ 34. Composite mold making — Canuck Engineering: https://www.canuckengineering.com/capabilities/composite-molds/