# Code Review Report

**Batch**: 01 (cycle 5) — AZ-504 (1 SP)
**Date**: 2026-05-12
**Verdict**: PASS

## Phase Summary

| Phase | Result |
|-------|--------|
| 1. Context Loading | OK — task spec read; intent = tolerate grep exit 1 on no-match while preserving occurrence-count semantics; do NOT change PT-08 threshold or production code. |
| 2. Spec Compliance | OK — AC-1 + AC-2 verified in standalone harness under `set -e -o pipefail`. AC-3 + AC-4 staged by spec design (AC-4 GIVEN clause couples them to the Step 15 full perf run). No Spec-Gap. |
| 3. Code Quality | OK — `\|\| true` is locally scoped, accompanied by an 8-line comment explaining why grep cannot fail for I/O at this code path; coderule.mdc allows this with comment. Mirror-image accepted/rejected lines are intentional, not duplication worth extracting. |
| 4. Security Quick-Scan | OK — no SQL, no command injection, no secrets, no input validation touch. |
| 5. Performance Scan | OK — same `grep -o \| wc -l` complexity as before; `\|\| true` adds zero overhead on the happy path. |
| 6. Cross-Task Consistency | N/A — single-task batch. |
| 7. Architecture Compliance | N/A — shell script, not in any C# component; no layer / Public API / cycle / duplicate-symbol concerns. |

## Findings

None.

## Notes

- Risk 1 (compact JSON vs `grep -c`) was verified empirically against `SatelliteProvider.Common/DTO/UavTileBatchUploadResponse.cs` — the ASP.NET Core default serializer emits the full `Items` list on a single line. `grep -c` would have collapsed all occurrences to a line count of 1. The chosen fix (`grep -o ... \|\| true \| wc -l`) preserves occurrence semantics. The 8-line in-script comment captures this so a future maintainer doesn't re-introduce `grep -c`.
- Risk 2 (other vulnerable `grep ... \| wc -l` sites) — Grep pass over the whole script found only the two sites named in the spec (416, 417). The third `grep -o` site (line 141, region status polling) is protected by `head -1 \|\| true`. No other defensive work required.
- Test infra note — no BATS/shell-test framework in this project. Adding one for a 1-SP fix is infra creep. The standalone harness in the batch report is the established equivalent verification.

## Verdict

**PASS** — no findings of any severity. Proceed to commit. AC-3 + AC-4 are Step 15 obligations, not Step 10 gaps.
