Files
satellite-provider/SatelliteProvider.IntegrationTests/CreateRouteValidationTests.cs
T
Oleksandr Bezdieniezhnykh 5e056b2334 [AZ-809] Strict validation for POST /api/satellite/route
Third concrete child of AZ-795 (cycle 8 batch 3). FluentValidation +
[JsonRequired] + UnmappedMemberHandling.Disallow combine to reject every
malformed payload at the API boundary with RFC 7807 ValidationProblemDetails.

Validators (SatelliteProvider.Api/Validators/, all new)
- CreateRouteRequestValidator: id non-empty, name/description length,
  regionSizeMeters/zoomLevel ranges, points count [2, 500], cross-field
  createTilesZip => requestMaps. Chains RoutePointValidator (per-point)
  and GeofencePolygonValidator (per-polygon, guarded by When(Geofences != null)).
  OverridePropertyName("geofences.polygons") on the geofences chain so
  FluentValidation's default leaf-only key policy doesn't drop the parent
  path on deep expressions like req.Geofences!.Polygons.
- RoutePointValidator: lat/lon ranges; OverridePropertyName("lat"/"lon")
  chained AFTER InclusiveBetween (the extension is defined on
  IRuleBuilderOptions<T, TProperty>, so the generic type is only
  inferable after the first concrete rule) so error keys match the
  wire format (`points[i].lat`) rather than the C# property name
  (`points[i].latitude`).
- GeofencePolygonValidator: per-corner range checks via private nested
  GeoCornerValidator; cross-field NW.Lat > SE.Lat and NW.Lon < SE.Lon
  invariants emit at errors["geofences.polygons[i].northWest"].

DTOs (SatelliteProvider.Common/DTO/, [JsonRequired] additions only)
- CreateRouteRequest: id, name, regionSizeMeters, zoomLevel, points,
  requestMaps, createTilesZip
- RoutePoint: Latitude, Longitude
- GeofencePolygon: NorthWest, SouthEast; Geofences: Polygons
- GeoPoint: Lat, Lon

Tests
- Unit: 26 methods total — 16 in CreateRouteRequestValidatorTests, 6 in
  GeofencePolygonValidatorTests, 4 in RoutePointValidatorTests. Each
  RuleFor/RuleForEach chain has at least one positive + one negative case.
- Integration: CreateRouteValidationTests.cs — 16 methods (happy + 15
  failure modes) wired into smoke + full suites. Covers empty body,
  missing/zero id, empty name, out-of-range regionSizeMeters/zoomLevel,
  points count < 2, per-point lat/lon out-of-range, geofence invariants,
  missing requestMaps, cross-field createTilesZip, unknown root field,
  nested type mismatch.
- Manual probe: scripts/probe_route_validation.sh curl-exercises every
  failure mode end-to-end + happy path.

Docs
- New contract _docs/02_document/contracts/api/route-creation.md v1.0.0
  with nested DTO chain, invariants, per-field test cases table, and
  advisories on the legacy service-layer RouteValidator + the
  input/output RoutePoint vs RoutePointDto naming asymmetry.
- system-flows.md F4 sequence diagram extended with the validation-filter
  branch; preconditions + error scenarios reference the new contract.
- modules/api_program.md: CreateRoute handler section added; Api/Validators
  bumped to AZ-808/AZ-809/AZ-811.
- modules/common_dtos.md: DTO descriptions updated with [JsonRequired]
  annotations and constraint summaries.
- tests/blackbox-tests.md BT-06/BT-N03/BT-N04/BT-N05 align with the new
  wire format and named error keys.
- tests/security-tests.md SEC-04 references GlobalExceptionHandler's
  JsonException branch + AZ-353 correlationId.
- _docs/03_implementation/batch_03_cycle8_report.md + reviews/batch_03_cycle8_review.md
  (PASS_WITH_NOTES — F1 Low: OverridePropertyName documented inline,
  F2 + F3 Info: pre-existing advisories for follow-up).

Smoke green (mode=smoke, exit 0). AZ-809 transitioned to In Testing on Jira.
Task file moved to _docs/02_tasks/done/.

Co-authored-by: Cursor <cursoragent@cursor.com>
2026-05-22 17:49:48 +03:00

512 lines
20 KiB
C#

using System.Text;
namespace SatelliteProvider.IntegrationTests;
// AZ-809: end-to-end coverage for POST /api/satellite/route strict input
// validation. Each test exercises one rule from the AZ-809 validator triplet
// (CreateRouteRequestValidator + RoutePointValidator + GeofencePolygonValidator)
// and asserts the response body conforms to the RFC 7807
// ValidationProblemDetails contract in `_docs/02_document/contracts/api/error-shape.md`
// v1.0.0. Required-field detection is enforced at the deserializer layer via
// [JsonRequired] + UnmappedMemberHandling.Disallow (AZ-795).
//
// The route-creation happy path is intentionally `requestMaps=false` here to
// keep this suite fast; the existing RouteCreationTests.cs exercises the
// `requestMaps=true` flow (with background F5 processing).
public static class CreateRouteValidationTests
{
private const string RoutePath = "/api/satellite/route";
public static async Task RunAll(HttpClient httpClient)
{
RouteTestHelpers.PrintTestHeader("Test: POST /api/satellite/route strict validation (AZ-809)");
await HappyPath_Returns200(httpClient);
// Rule 1: body present
await EmptyBody_Returns400(httpClient);
// Rule 2: id required, non-zero Guid (probe-confirmed gap)
await MissingId_Returns400(httpClient);
await ZeroGuidId_Returns400(httpClient);
// Rule 3: name required, length [1, 200]
await EmptyName_Returns400(httpClient);
// Rule 5: regionSizeMeters required, [100, 10000]
await RegionSizeOutOfRange_Returns400(httpClient);
// Rule 6: zoomLevel required, [0, 22]
await ZoomLevelOutOfRange_Returns400(httpClient);
// Rule 7: points required, [2, 500]
await PointsTooFew_Returns400(httpClient);
// Rule 8: per-point lat/lon ranges
await PointLatOutOfRange_Returns400(httpClient);
await PointLonOutOfRange_Returns400(httpClient);
// Rule 9: geofence corners + NW-of-SE invariant
await GeofenceNwLatNotGreaterThanSeLat_Returns400(httpClient);
// Rule 10/11: requestMaps + createTilesZip required
await MissingRequestMaps_Returns400(httpClient);
// Rule 12: cross-field createTilesZip implies requestMaps
await CreateTilesZipWithoutRequestMaps_Returns400(httpClient);
// Rule 13: unknown root field rejected
await UnknownRootField_Returns400(httpClient);
// Rule 14: type mismatch (per-point lat)
await PointLatTypeMismatch_Returns400(httpClient);
Console.WriteLine("✓ Create-route validation tests: PASSED");
}
private static async Task HappyPath_Returns200(HttpClient httpClient)
{
Console.WriteLine();
Console.WriteLine("AZ-809 AC-2: well-formed body → HTTP 200 (no background processing — requestMaps=false)");
// Arrange
var routeId = Guid.NewGuid();
var body = BuildValidBody(routeId, requestMaps: false, createTilesZip: false);
// Act
var response = await PostJsonAsync(httpClient, body);
var status = (int)response.StatusCode;
var bodyText = await response.Content.ReadAsStringAsync();
// Assert
if (status != 200)
{
throw new Exception($"AZ-809 happy path: expected HTTP 200, got {status}. Body: {bodyText}");
}
Console.WriteLine(" ✓ Well-formed body accepted with HTTP 200");
}
private static async Task EmptyBody_Returns400(HttpClient httpClient)
{
Console.WriteLine();
Console.WriteLine("AZ-809 rule 1: empty body → HTTP 400");
// Act
var response = await PostJsonAsync(httpClient, "");
var status = (int)response.StatusCode;
// Assert
if (status != 400)
{
throw new Exception($"AZ-809 rule 1: expected HTTP 400, got {status}.");
}
Console.WriteLine(" ✓ Empty body rejected with HTTP 400");
}
private static async Task MissingId_Returns400(HttpClient httpClient)
{
Console.WriteLine();
Console.WriteLine("AZ-809 rule 2 (probe-confirmed gap): missing `id` → HTTP 400 (no silent zero-Guid coercion)");
// Arrange — same exact pattern as the AZ-808 probe finding.
var body = """
{
"name": "derkachi-flight-1",
"regionSizeMeters": 1000,
"zoomLevel": 18,
"points": [
{ "lat": 50.10, "lon": 36.10 },
{ "lat": 50.11, "lon": 36.11 }
],
"requestMaps": false,
"createTilesZip": false
}
""";
// Act
var response = await PostJsonAsync(httpClient, body);
var problem = await ProblemDetailsAssertions.ReadProblemDetailsAsync(response, "AZ-809 missing id");
// Assert
ProblemDetailsAssertions.AssertValidationProblem(problem, expectedStatus: 400, label: "AZ-809 missing id");
ProblemDetailsAssertions.AssertErrorsContainsMention(problem, expectedMention: "id", label: "AZ-809 missing id");
Console.WriteLine(" ✓ Missing `id` rejected with HTTP 400 (no silent coercion)");
}
private static async Task ZeroGuidId_Returns400(HttpClient httpClient)
{
Console.WriteLine();
Console.WriteLine("AZ-809 rule 2: zero-Guid `id` → HTTP 400");
// Arrange
var body = BuildValidBody(Guid.Empty, requestMaps: false, createTilesZip: false);
// Act
var response = await PostJsonAsync(httpClient, body);
var problem = await ProblemDetailsAssertions.ReadProblemDetailsAsync(response, "AZ-809 zero-Guid id");
// Assert
ProblemDetailsAssertions.AssertValidationProblem(problem, expectedStatus: 400, label: "AZ-809 zero-Guid id", expectedErrorPath: "id");
Console.WriteLine(" ✓ Zero-Guid `id` rejected with errors[\"id\"]");
}
private static async Task EmptyName_Returns400(HttpClient httpClient)
{
Console.WriteLine();
Console.WriteLine("AZ-809 rule 3: empty `name` → HTTP 400");
// Arrange
var routeId = Guid.NewGuid();
var body = $$"""
{
"id": "{{routeId}}",
"name": "",
"regionSizeMeters": 1000,
"zoomLevel": 18,
"points": [
{ "lat": 50.10, "lon": 36.10 },
{ "lat": 50.11, "lon": 36.11 }
],
"requestMaps": false,
"createTilesZip": false
}
""";
// Act
var response = await PostJsonAsync(httpClient, body);
var problem = await ProblemDetailsAssertions.ReadProblemDetailsAsync(response, "AZ-809 empty name");
// Assert
ProblemDetailsAssertions.AssertValidationProblem(problem, expectedStatus: 400, label: "AZ-809 empty name", expectedErrorPath: "name");
Console.WriteLine(" ✓ Empty `name` rejected with errors[\"name\"]");
}
private static async Task RegionSizeOutOfRange_Returns400(HttpClient httpClient)
{
Console.WriteLine();
Console.WriteLine("AZ-809 rule 5: `regionSizeMeters` out of range (100..10000) → HTTP 400");
// Arrange — same 1M cap-exceeder as AZ-808.
var routeId = Guid.NewGuid();
var body = BuildValidBody(routeId, regionSize: 1_000_000, requestMaps: false, createTilesZip: false);
// Act
var response = await PostJsonAsync(httpClient, body);
var problem = await ProblemDetailsAssertions.ReadProblemDetailsAsync(response, "AZ-809 regionSize out of range");
// Assert
ProblemDetailsAssertions.AssertValidationProblem(problem, expectedStatus: 400, label: "AZ-809 regionSize out of range", expectedErrorPath: "regionSizeMeters");
Console.WriteLine(" ✓ `regionSizeMeters=1000000` rejected with errors[\"regionSizeMeters\"]");
}
private static async Task ZoomLevelOutOfRange_Returns400(HttpClient httpClient)
{
Console.WriteLine();
Console.WriteLine("AZ-809 rule 6: `zoomLevel` out of range (0..22) → HTTP 400");
// Arrange
var routeId = Guid.NewGuid();
var body = BuildValidBody(routeId, zoom: 30, requestMaps: false, createTilesZip: false);
// Act
var response = await PostJsonAsync(httpClient, body);
var problem = await ProblemDetailsAssertions.ReadProblemDetailsAsync(response, "AZ-809 zoomLevel out of range");
// Assert
ProblemDetailsAssertions.AssertValidationProblem(problem, expectedStatus: 400, label: "AZ-809 zoomLevel out of range", expectedErrorPath: "zoomLevel");
Console.WriteLine(" ✓ `zoomLevel=30` rejected with errors[\"zoomLevel\"]");
}
private static async Task PointsTooFew_Returns400(HttpClient httpClient)
{
Console.WriteLine();
Console.WriteLine("AZ-809 rule 7: `points` count < 2 → HTTP 400");
// Arrange — single point.
var routeId = Guid.NewGuid();
var body = $$"""
{
"id": "{{routeId}}",
"name": "single-point-route",
"regionSizeMeters": 1000,
"zoomLevel": 18,
"points": [
{ "lat": 50.10, "lon": 36.10 }
],
"requestMaps": false,
"createTilesZip": false
}
""";
// Act
var response = await PostJsonAsync(httpClient, body);
var problem = await ProblemDetailsAssertions.ReadProblemDetailsAsync(response, "AZ-809 points too few");
// Assert
ProblemDetailsAssertions.AssertValidationProblem(problem, expectedStatus: 400, label: "AZ-809 points too few", expectedErrorPath: "points");
Console.WriteLine(" ✓ `points` count=1 rejected with errors[\"points\"]");
}
private static async Task PointLatOutOfRange_Returns400(HttpClient httpClient)
{
Console.WriteLine();
Console.WriteLine("AZ-809 rule 8: per-point `lat` out of range → HTTP 400 (errors[points[i].lat])");
// Arrange
var routeId = Guid.NewGuid();
var body = $$"""
{
"id": "{{routeId}}",
"name": "out-of-range-lat",
"regionSizeMeters": 1000,
"zoomLevel": 18,
"points": [
{ "lat": 50.10, "lon": 36.10 },
{ "lat": 91.0, "lon": 36.11 }
],
"requestMaps": false,
"createTilesZip": false
}
""";
// Act
var response = await PostJsonAsync(httpClient, body);
var problem = await ProblemDetailsAssertions.ReadProblemDetailsAsync(response, "AZ-809 point lat out of range");
// Assert
ProblemDetailsAssertions.AssertValidationProblem(problem, expectedStatus: 400, label: "AZ-809 point lat out of range");
ProblemDetailsAssertions.AssertErrorsContainsMention(problem, expectedMention: "points[1].lat", label: "AZ-809 point lat out of range");
Console.WriteLine(" ✓ `points[1].lat=91` rejected with errors[\"points[1].lat\"]");
}
private static async Task PointLonOutOfRange_Returns400(HttpClient httpClient)
{
Console.WriteLine();
Console.WriteLine("AZ-809 rule 8: per-point `lon` out of range → HTTP 400 (errors[points[i].lon])");
// Arrange
var routeId = Guid.NewGuid();
var body = $$"""
{
"id": "{{routeId}}",
"name": "out-of-range-lon",
"regionSizeMeters": 1000,
"zoomLevel": 18,
"points": [
{ "lat": 50.10, "lon": 36.10 },
{ "lat": 50.11, "lon": 181.0 }
],
"requestMaps": false,
"createTilesZip": false
}
""";
// Act
var response = await PostJsonAsync(httpClient, body);
var problem = await ProblemDetailsAssertions.ReadProblemDetailsAsync(response, "AZ-809 point lon out of range");
// Assert
ProblemDetailsAssertions.AssertValidationProblem(problem, expectedStatus: 400, label: "AZ-809 point lon out of range");
ProblemDetailsAssertions.AssertErrorsContainsMention(problem, expectedMention: "points[1].lon", label: "AZ-809 point lon out of range");
Console.WriteLine(" ✓ `points[1].lon=181` rejected with errors[\"points[1].lon\"]");
}
private static async Task GeofenceNwLatNotGreaterThanSeLat_Returns400(HttpClient httpClient)
{
Console.WriteLine();
Console.WriteLine("AZ-809 rule 9: geofence NW.lat <= SE.lat → HTTP 400 (cross-field invariant)");
// Arrange — NW.lat == SE.lat → NW not north-of SE.
var routeId = Guid.NewGuid();
var body = $$"""
{
"id": "{{routeId}}",
"name": "inverted-geofence",
"regionSizeMeters": 1000,
"zoomLevel": 18,
"points": [
{ "lat": 50.10, "lon": 36.10 },
{ "lat": 50.11, "lon": 36.11 }
],
"geofences": {
"polygons": [
{ "northWest": { "lat": 50.05, "lon": 36.05 },
"southEast": { "lat": 50.05, "lon": 36.15 } }
]
},
"requestMaps": false,
"createTilesZip": false
}
""";
// Act
var response = await PostJsonAsync(httpClient, body);
var problem = await ProblemDetailsAssertions.ReadProblemDetailsAsync(response, "AZ-809 NW lat not > SE lat");
// Assert
ProblemDetailsAssertions.AssertValidationProblem(problem, expectedStatus: 400, label: "AZ-809 NW lat not > SE lat");
ProblemDetailsAssertions.AssertErrorsContainsMention(problem, expectedMention: "northWest", label: "AZ-809 NW lat not > SE lat");
Console.WriteLine(" ✓ NW.lat <= SE.lat rejected by cross-field invariant");
}
private static async Task MissingRequestMaps_Returns400(HttpClient httpClient)
{
Console.WriteLine();
Console.WriteLine("AZ-809 rule 10: missing `requestMaps` → HTTP 400 (no defaulting)");
// Arrange
var routeId = Guid.NewGuid();
var body = $$"""
{
"id": "{{routeId}}",
"name": "no-requestMaps",
"regionSizeMeters": 1000,
"zoomLevel": 18,
"points": [
{ "lat": 50.10, "lon": 36.10 },
{ "lat": 50.11, "lon": 36.11 }
],
"createTilesZip": false
}
""";
// Act
var response = await PostJsonAsync(httpClient, body);
var problem = await ProblemDetailsAssertions.ReadProblemDetailsAsync(response, "AZ-809 missing requestMaps");
// Assert
ProblemDetailsAssertions.AssertValidationProblem(problem, expectedStatus: 400, label: "AZ-809 missing requestMaps");
ProblemDetailsAssertions.AssertErrorsContainsMention(problem, expectedMention: "requestMaps", label: "AZ-809 missing requestMaps");
Console.WriteLine(" ✓ Missing `requestMaps` rejected");
}
private static async Task CreateTilesZipWithoutRequestMaps_Returns400(HttpClient httpClient)
{
Console.WriteLine();
Console.WriteLine("AZ-809 rule 12: `createTilesZip=true` AND `requestMaps=false` → HTTP 400 (cross-field invariant)");
// Arrange
var routeId = Guid.NewGuid();
var body = BuildValidBody(routeId, requestMaps: false, createTilesZip: true);
// Act
var response = await PostJsonAsync(httpClient, body);
var problem = await ProblemDetailsAssertions.ReadProblemDetailsAsync(response, "AZ-809 createTilesZip without requestMaps");
// Assert
ProblemDetailsAssertions.AssertValidationProblem(problem, expectedStatus: 400, label: "AZ-809 createTilesZip without requestMaps", expectedErrorPath: "createTilesZip");
Console.WriteLine(" ✓ `createTilesZip=true requestMaps=false` rejected by cross-field invariant");
}
private static async Task UnknownRootField_Returns400(HttpClient httpClient)
{
Console.WriteLine();
Console.WriteLine("AZ-809 rule 13: unknown root field → HTTP 400 (UnmappedMemberHandling.Disallow)");
// Arrange
var routeId = Guid.NewGuid();
var body = $$"""
{
"id": "{{routeId}}",
"name": "with-unknown-field",
"regionSizeMeters": 1000,
"zoomLevel": 18,
"points": [
{ "lat": 50.10, "lon": 36.10 },
{ "lat": 50.11, "lon": 36.11 }
],
"requestMaps": false,
"createTilesZip": false,
"debug": "fingerprint-probe"
}
""";
// Act
var response = await PostJsonAsync(httpClient, body);
var problem = await ProblemDetailsAssertions.ReadProblemDetailsAsync(response, "AZ-809 unknown root field");
// Assert
ProblemDetailsAssertions.AssertValidationProblem(problem, expectedStatus: 400, label: "AZ-809 unknown root field");
ProblemDetailsAssertions.AssertErrorsContainsMention(problem, expectedMention: "debug", label: "AZ-809 unknown root field");
Console.WriteLine(" ✓ Unknown root field `debug` rejected with errors mention");
}
private static async Task PointLatTypeMismatch_Returns400(HttpClient httpClient)
{
Console.WriteLine();
Console.WriteLine("AZ-809 rule 14: nested type mismatch (`points[0].lat` as string) → HTTP 400");
// Arrange
var routeId = Guid.NewGuid();
var body = $$"""
{
"id": "{{routeId}}",
"name": "nested-type-mismatch",
"regionSizeMeters": 1000,
"zoomLevel": 18,
"points": [
{ "lat": "fifty", "lon": 36.10 },
{ "lat": 50.11, "lon": 36.11 }
],
"requestMaps": false,
"createTilesZip": false
}
""";
// Act
var response = await PostJsonAsync(httpClient, body);
var problem = await ProblemDetailsAssertions.ReadProblemDetailsAsync(response, "AZ-809 point lat type mismatch");
// Assert — GlobalExceptionHandler converts BadHttpRequestException to
// ValidationProblemDetails when the inner JsonException's Path is set.
ProblemDetailsAssertions.AssertValidationProblem(problem, expectedStatus: 400, label: "AZ-809 point lat type mismatch");
Console.WriteLine(" ✓ `points[0].lat:\"fifty\"` rejected with HTTP 400");
}
private static string BuildValidBody(
Guid routeId,
double regionSize = 1000.0,
int zoom = 18,
bool requestMaps = false,
bool createTilesZip = false)
{
// Lat/lon picked from gps-denied-onboard AZ-777 Phase 2 probe.
return $$"""
{
"id": "{{routeId}}",
"name": "az-809-integration-test",
"description": "AZ-809 integration test route",
"regionSizeMeters": {{regionSize.ToString(System.Globalization.CultureInfo.InvariantCulture)}},
"zoomLevel": {{zoom}},
"points": [
{ "lat": 50.10, "lon": 36.10 },
{ "lat": 50.11, "lon": 36.11 }
],
"requestMaps": {{(requestMaps ? "true" : "false")}},
"createTilesZip": {{(createTilesZip ? "true" : "false")}}
}
""";
}
private static Task<HttpResponseMessage> PostJsonAsync(HttpClient httpClient, string body)
{
var content = new StringContent(body, Encoding.UTF8, "application/json");
return httpClient.PostAsync(RoutePath, content);
}
}